TRACT BABA METZIA (MIDDLE GATE).
CHAPTER II.
LAWS RELATING TO FOUND ARTICLES, WHICH MAY OR MAY NOT BE KEPT WITHOUT PROCLAMATION, AND HOW FOUND ARTICLES SHALL BE CARED FOR, ETC.
P. 79
R. Jehudah b. Ilayi lectured as
follows: "It is written [Isaiah, xvi. 5]: 'Hear the
word of the Lord, ye that tremble of his word. Your brethren that
hated you, that cast you out for the sake of my name, said, Let the Lord be
glorified, but he will appear to your joy, and they
shall be made ashamed.'" "Tremble of his word" means
the scholars who study Gemara; "your brethren"
means those who study the Scripture; "that hated you"
means the students of the Mishnayoth (the students of the Mishnayoth, says
Rashi, hated the students of the Gemara, because
the latter had decided that the students of the Mishnayoth, without
Gemara, are the destroyers of the world, because they act according to the
Mishnayoth without knowledge of their sources
and bases, and very often the Halakha does not prevail according
to their decisions); "that cast you out" means the common people. But
lest one say their hope has ceased, therefore it
is written: "He will appear to your joy"; and may one say that Israel will be ashamed, therefore it is written:
"And they (the idolaters) shall be ashamed, and Israel
will rejoice." 1
Footnotes
79:1 This remarkable statement is interpreted by Rashi
thus: When the disciples of Shamai and Hillel increased
to a great number (about three generations before Rabbi), differing and quarrelling so, that it looked as if there were two
Torahs. In addition to this, persecution by the government
was increased daily, and new disagreeable decisions were renewed day by day, so that they could not give the proper attention to revise
the point of their differences, until the days of
Rabbi. When the Almighty gave him grace in the eyes of Antoninus Cæsar of
Rome, who abolished all the disagreeable decisions, and Rabbi had the
opportunity to compile the Mishnayoth, which
was oral until his time. He assembled all the disciples of Palestine, and each of them had to report a Halakha which he
had heard from a great man, which was written down in the name of each author,
and only then the sections of the Mishnayoth were classified; i. e.,
the Halakhas which belong to damages, women, festivals, etc., were selected,
separated in sections.
Rabbi, however, omitted from some Mishnayoth the name of
their author for the purpose of establishing the Halakha accordingly, which
probably could not be done if it were taught in the name of individuals, and
when this was done, the Mishna mentioned in the text was said, i.e.,
"there is not a better custom than to study the Gemara," which means,
to understand the sources and reasons of the decisions of the Mishnayoth. But when
Rabbi saw that all had occupied themselves with the study of Gemara,
without repeating the Mishnayoth itself, he was afraid that the name of the
sages and the obligation would be changed, so he lectured again:
"Occupy thyself with Mishnayoth." See our brief general
introduction, Section Festivals, Vol. I., p. xv, in which we give the history
of the Mishnayoth differently, the basis of our opinion being the majority,
who differ with Rashi, and say that the Mishnayoth was written down
many generations before the time of Rabbi. In our periodical
"Hakol," Vol. VI., No. 2, we published an article pointing out all
the names of them who agree with Rashi and all those who are contrary, also the
opinion of the late famous Dr. Gellenik. See also "Dour Dour
Vedourshow,"
by I. H. Wise. All details of this matter for the English reader
will be found in our forthcoming history of the Talmud.